Transubstantiation -- Controversial literature -- Early Works to 1800

Number of relevant publications in EEBO-TCP: 1
Navigate to the catalog to search for the relevant publications associated with this this referencing entity.



Textual Features and Statistics

Nota Bene: QP stands for "quotation/paraphrase." A "unit" stands for a segment produced by EEPS' segmentation unit or an individual marginal note. Adjacent references are those that are located in the same or adjacent segment or note. Chapter-level citations are relevant if the chapter matches that of the query. For book-level queries, all references to the same Bible book are relevant. A "Latin Bible QP" is a quotation or paraphrase of any verse from a Bible that follows the Latin Vulgate tradition: the Vulgate, Douay-Rheims Version, the ODRV, and Wycliffe's version.
Feature Description In-Text Marginal
cited Percentage of units with QP and an adjacent citation 2.3% 2.2%
cited_exact Percentage of units with QP and an adjacent matching citation 0.8% -inf%
originality Percentage of units that do not exhibit scriptural text reuse 82.6% 93.3%
Foreign Percentage of units with foreign text 0.6% -inf%
Italicization Percentage of units with italicized spans of text 7.6% 6.7%
sim_score Average cosine similarity score of top Bible verse predictions per unit 0.7% 0.8%
cross_score Average cross encoder score of top Bible verse predictions per unit 0.6% 0.6%
near_quotations Percentage of units that have high lexical similarity with their Bible verse predictions (any type of score greater than the mean + standard deviation of that score type) 1.5% -inf%
foreign_cited Percentage of units with QP, foreign text, and an adjacent citation 0.2% -inf%
foreign_italicized Percentage of units with QP and foreign italicized text 0.4% -inf%
foreign_latin Percentage of units with Latin Bible QP and foreign text 0.4% -inf%
foreign_latin_italicized Percentage of units with Latin Bible QP and italicized foreign text 0.4% -inf%



Quotations and Paraphrases

Rather than examine the frequency or proportion of references, it is far more useful to determine which references are most prominent for a citing entity. The visualizations below show the most prominent scriptural references within all publications per year. Prominence, displayed as the value below each label, is measured using the metric of Outgoing Relative Citational Prominence (ORCP) proposed by Wahle et al. (2023). In this case, a positive prominence value for a reference R in a given year means that R constitutes a greater percentage of all the references cited by publications in that year than the average citation percentage of R per year. A negative value indicates that a given reference constitutes a proportion lesser than average. A value of negative infinity means that the query reference does not occur in the citation or QP of a citing entity. A value of "%" (without any numeral value) means that there are no citations or QP corresponding to the query reference.

For quotational prominence, only the predictions with the highest cosine similarity scores for each subsegmented or whole unit of a segment or note are included for consideration. The average quotational prominence for a citing entity is the mean of the prominence percentage points for all references R_ALL that are relevant to the query reference such that each reference R in R_ALL has the highest cosine similarity score with a part or the whole of its covering body segment or marginal note. The percentages of top predictions from each Bible version are displayed in a table below.

For citational prominence, only pluasible scriptural citations and ones where the original phrase does not begin with a lowercase word are included for consideration. A scriptural citation is plausible if its numbering exists in any of the Bibles considered by this project. There are over 76 thousand such excluded candidates out of 1.2 million parsed citational units in total. Each of the four side-by-side tables below also have associated diversity and evenness scores; Simpson's Diversity Index ranges from 0 to 1 such that a higher score indicates a greater species diversity. Likewise, the Shannon Index indicates more evenness in the distribution of individuals in a group when its value approaches 1.


Diversity: 0.697
Evenness: 0.758
Part Prominence
New Testament (AKJV) 26.83
New Testament (Geneva) 24.24
New Testament (Wycliffe) 5.591
New Testament (ODRV) 3.782
New Testament (Vulgate) -3.094
New Testament (Tyndale) -7.929
Diversity: 0.851
Evenness: 0.769
Book Prominence
1 Corinthians (AKJV) 25.055
1 Corinthians (Geneva) 22.849
Matthew (ODRV) 8.769
Matthew (Wycliffe) 4.969
John (Geneva) 2.94
Matthew (Tyndale) 2.775
John (ODRV) 2.749
Colossians (Vulgate) 2.444
John (AKJV) 1.372
John (Vulgate) 1.073
Mark (ODRV) 1.064
Matthew (Vulgate) 1.012
1 Corinthians (Vulgate) 0.985
Colossians (Geneva) 0.886
Ephesians (Tyndale) 0.83
1 John (Geneva) 0.818
Colossians (AKJV) 0.74
Luke (Tyndale) 0.527
1 Corinthians (Tyndale) 0.446
John (Tyndale) 0.429
Luke (ODRV) 0.33
1 Corinthians (ODRV) 0.122
Luke (AKJV) 0.089
Diversity: 0.892
Evenness: 0.802
Chapter Prominence
1 Corinthians 10 (AKJV) 21.831
1 Corinthians 10 (Geneva) 19.833
Matthew 26 (ODRV) 8.35
1 Corinthians 10 (ODRV) 5.131
Matthew 26 (Wycliffe) 4.205
Matthew 26 (Tyndale) 3.066
John 6 (Geneva) 3.061
John 6 (ODRV) 3.026
1 Corinthians 11 (AKJV) 2.947
Colossians 2 (Vulgate) 2.094
John 6 (AKJV) 2.005
Matthew 26 (Vulgate) 1.048
1 Corinthians 11 (Vulgate) 1.04
Mark 10 (ODRV) 1.04
1 Corinthians 10 (Vulgate) 1.033
John 6 (Vulgate) 1.032
1 John 1 (Geneva) 1.028
Luke 24 (AKJV) 1.024
John 20 (Tyndale) 1.016
Luke 18 (Tyndale) 1.014
1 Corinthians 2 (Tyndale) 0.993
Luke 18 (ODRV) 0.984
Ephesians 4 (Tyndale) 0.979
Colossians 2 (Geneva) 0.972
1 Corinthians 11 (Tyndale) 0.959
1 Corinthians 11 (Geneva) 0.957
Colossians 2 (AKJV) 0.952
John 6 (Tyndale) 0.95
Colossians 1 (Geneva) 0.948
1 Corinthians 11 (ODRV) 0.922
John 3 (Tyndale) 0.919
1 Corinthians 15 (AKJV) 0.827
1 Corinthians 15 (Geneva) 0.792
Diversity: 0.934
Evenness: 0.847
Verse Prominence
1 Corinthians 10.16 (AKJV) 16.859
1 Corinthians 10.16 (Geneva) 15.247
Matthew 26.26 (ODRV) 6.439
1 Corinthians 10.16 (ODRV) 4.005
Matthew 26.26 (Wycliffe) 3.223
John 6.53 (ODRV) 2.417
John 6.51 (Geneva) 2.416
1 Corinthians 11.27 (Tyndale) 2.407
1 Corinthians 11.24 (AKJV) 2.399
Matthew 26.26 (Tyndale) 2.393
Colossians 2.17 (Vulgate) 1.611
John 6.51 (AKJV) 1.61
John 6.58 (AKJV) 1.609
John 6.51 (ODRV) 1.608
1 Corinthians 11.29 (AKJV) 1.596
1 Corinthians 11.25 (AKJV) 1.594
1 Corinthians 15.5 (AKJV) 0.806
1 Corinthians 15.5 (Geneva) 0.806
John 6.61 (Tyndale) 0.806
John 6.33 (Vulgate) 0.805
1 Corinthians 11.24 (Vulgate) 0.805
Matthew 26.26 (Vulgate) 0.805
John 6.50 (Vulgate) 0.805
John 6.50 (ODRV) 0.805
Ephesians 4.5 (Tyndale) 0.805
Luke 24.39 (AKJV) 0.805
Luke 18.27 (ODRV) 0.805
1 Corinthians 2.16 (Tyndale) 0.804
Matthew 26.29 (Tyndale) 0.804
John 6.63 (ODRV) 0.804
John 20.27 (Tyndale) 0.804
1 Corinthians 11.29 (Geneva) 0.803
1 John 1.1 (Geneva) 0.803
Mark 10.27 (ODRV) 0.803
Luke 18.27 (Tyndale) 0.803
1 Corinthians 10.17 (Vulgate) 0.802
John 6.54 (ODRV) 0.802
Colossians 2.7 (AKJV) 0.801
John 6.53 (Geneva) 0.801
John 6.55 (Geneva) 0.8
John 6.48 (AKJV) 0.8
John 6.48 (Geneva) 0.8
1 Corinthians 10.3 (Geneva) 0.8
Colossians 2.6 (Geneva) 0.798
1 Corinthians 11.26 (Geneva) 0.798
John 6.48 (ODRV) 0.797
Colossians 2.17 (AKJV) 0.795
1 Corinthians 11.28 (ODRV) 0.795
John 6.50 (AKJV) 0.795
John 6.52 (ODRV) 0.795
1 Corinthians 11.24 (Geneva) 0.791
Colossians 1.14 (Geneva) 0.791
1 Corinthians 11.19 (ODRV) 0.79
1 Corinthians 11.20 (Tyndale) 0.778
John 6.55 (ODRV) 0.773
John 3.13 (Tyndale) 0.757
Segment No., Location Verse & Version Verse Text Text Is a Partial Textual Segment/Note Adjacent References Cosine Similarity Score Cross Encoder Score Okapi BM25 Score



Citations
i
The index of citation indicates its position within the text of the segment or a particular note of the segment. For example, if 'Note 0' (i.e., the first note) of this segment has three citations, the citation with index 0 is its first citation, inclusive of all its parsed components.

Diversity: 0.0
Evenness: 1.0
Part Prominence
New Testament 52.093
Diversity: 0.667
Evenness: 1.0
Book Prominence
Colossians 31.926
Luke 30.232
1 Corinthians 30.117
Diversity: 0.75
Evenness: 1.0
Chapter Prominence
Luke 24 24.859
Luke 22 24.783
Colossians 2 24.764
1 Corinthians 15 24.556
Diversity: 0.75
Evenness: 1.0
Verse Prominence
1 Corinthians 15.5 24.985
Luke 24.29 24.984
Colossians 2.6 24.979
Luke 22.19 24.976
Segment No., Location Possible Citation Adjacent References Phrase